Eight years after launch, CleanMyMac X is still the benchmark Mac cleaner. We ran every module for a month on a real machine — here is what earns its disk space and what is cosmetic.
CleanMyMac X remains the most polished all-in-one Mac cleaner. The cleanup engine is genuinely deep and always inspectable before deletion; the Uninstaller and Space Lens alone justify the license for most users. Weak points: the "free RAM" button is cosmetic on Apple silicon, the malware module is a capable on-demand scanner rather than a lab-grade shield, and the full value requires paying — the free trial only cleans a limited amount. Score: a confident recommendation with the caveats in our safety notes.
System Junk sweeps caches, logs, language files and broken downloads; Mail Attachments and Trash Bins round it out. Found 18.4 GB on our test machine, every item inspectable.
Signature-based malware removal plus a genuinely useful permissions/privacy audit — one screen showing what can see your camera, mic and disk.
Login-item and Launch-Agent management plus classic maintenance scripts. The free-RAM action is cosmetic; Spotlight/Mail reindex actually fixes things.
The best module in the box: Uninstaller removes apps with all support files; Updater patches installed software centrally; Extensions audits browser add-ons.
Space Lens builds a clickable bubble-map of your entire disk; Large & Old Files is the same data sorted; Shredder securely deletes stubborn items.
MacPaw's 2024/2025 successor drops the "X" and reorganizes the same jobs under a new interface — cleanup, protection and optimization modules rearranged, plus a guided assistant. X keeps getting database updates and remains the choice for existing license holders and anyone who prefers its layout; new buyers get the new app by default. Feature-for-feature they are closer than the branding suggests.
The download is free and the trial runs a full Smart Scan, cleaning a limited amount so you can verify it works on your machine. Everything beyond that needs a license: annual subscription or one-time purchase via MacPaw's site, or included free inside a Setapp subscription — the most economical route if you use any other Setapp apps.